Christmas cookie box (and recipes!)

I spent last week baking my little heart out. I love baking. Not the dishes so much, but they don’t go away no matter how hard I try to ignore them, so I guess they come with the territory. It’s so relaxing for me, and luckily the girls love to “help”. Until they get bored and go make messes and change clothes a million times per day. (Sadie, at least)

I made a few different varieties of cookies, packaged them up and passed these treat boxes out to family and friends, and they were a hit, I heard! One family even called me a (and I quote) “freaking homemaking wizard”. I’m actually thinking of having a name plate for my desk made that says just that:

Jessica Christian
“Freaking Homemaking Wizard”
It’s one of the best compliments I’ve ever received. No kidding. 😉

These adorable treat boxes are from Martha Stewart’s line. They sent me some to try out, and they were fantastic! They make it so easy to put together a gorgeous treat assortment, and to make you look like a “homemaking wizard”.  I just love the scalloped edges! Who doesn’t love a good scallop? (and no I didn’t really give the Griswolds those goodies. They probably would have destroyed them in about 2 seconds anyways.)


I’ll share the recipes below for what I made! They all turned out delicious.

 I should know, I sampled them all…. a lot. 😉

Sugar cookies…of course! I love decorating sugar cookies so these had to make an appearance in my box! The recipe is below for the cookies, and I’m planning a post soon with more tips on royal icing so look for that…sometime. 😀

Sugar Cookies
 adapted from Annie’s Eats

 2 cups butter, softened
2 cups powdered sugar

2 eggs, beaten

1 ½ t. almond extract
2 t. vanilla
1 ½ t. salt
5 c. sifted flour

Cream butter. Add powdered sugar. Mix well. Blend in egg, almond extract, vanilla, salt and flour. Roll to ¼” thickness in between sheets of parchment paper (sprinkle flour on both sides of the dough and paper), then chill dough in fridge until firm. Cut with cookie cutters and place on greased cookie sheets. Repeat with remainder of dough, but keep in mind each time you roll it out they get tougher from adding flour while rolling. Bake at 375° for 8-10 min. Make sure they are not sitting on the counter very long before putting them in the oven, you want them to go in chilled. Cookies should not brown. Let cool for a few minutes on the tray then transfer to a cooling rack.  I usually bake them a day before I decorate. Makes about 40-50 cookies, depending on the size of your cutter design.

Royal Icing


  • 4 cups powdered sugar, sifted
  • 2 tbsp. meringue powder
  • 5 tbsp. water, plus more for thinning

Combine the powdered sugar, meringue powder, and water in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. Mix on low speed until the icing is thick. (about 5 minutes).  This will be the stiffest consistency of the icing, and from this point you can add water to thin it out for piping and flooding. Piping consistency is about toothpaste consistency, and flooding is thinner…but not too think, you don’t want it falling off the cookie! I usually double this recipe for the cookie recipe above!

Now onto the other cookies!

These cookies were so, so delish! I loved the texture of the pistachios and cranberries, and the colors were perfect for a Christmas cookie box! So easy to make, too.

Cranberry-Pistachio Cookies
 source: Betty Crocker
1 (1 lb 1.5 ounce) pouch Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix
1 box (4 serving size) pistachio instant pudding and pie filling mix
1/4 cup flour
1/2 cup butter, melted
2 eggs
1 cup dry roasted salted pistachio nuts, chopped
1/2 cup dried cranberries
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. In a large mixer add cookie mix, pudding mix, and flour. Add melted butter and eggs and mix until incorporated. Add pistachios and cranberries and mix well.
Drop by rounded spoonfuls onto a parchment lined cookie sheet and slightly flatten with your palm.
Bake for 8-10 minutes-make sure not to over bake, letting them sit on the counter for a few minutes helps them “set”. They were a bit wobbly when I got them out at 8 minutes (my oven is a bit hot), so I let them stay in for another 2-3, and they were just right. After they’ve set up on the pan, transfer and let them cool completely on a wire rack. Store in an airtight container. Makes about 2 dozen cookies.
These are a classic Christmas treat for our family. Rory LOVES peanut butter and chocolate so these are the cookies he requests most often around the holidays.

 Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies

2 2/3 cups flour
2 teaspoons baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
1 cup butter
2/3 cup creamy peanut butter
1 cup sugar
1 cup brown sugar, firmly packed
2 eggs
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
Additional sugar (about 1/3 cup, in a shallow bowl)
5 dozen kisses, unwrapped

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

In your mixer, mix flour, salt, and baking soda. Add butter and peanut butter then mix until smooth. Add brown and white sugars and beat until light and fluffy. Add eggs and vanilla and mix until smooth. Make balls of dough equaling about a tablespoon. Roll in sugar. (Sadie loved helping with this part!) Bake 2 inches apart on ungreased cookie sheet for 8 minutes. Remove from oven and add 1 kiss to the center of each cookie. Return to the oven and bake for 2 more minutes. Cool and enjoy!

Cookies and Cream Fudge

adapted from Chef in Training
1 cup sugar
3/4 cup butter
1 (5 oz.) can evaporated milk
2 (12 oz.) packages white chocolate morsels
1 (7 oz.) jar marshmallow cream
3 cups coarsely chopped Oreos (about 25 cookies)
 divided pinch of salt
Line a 9×13″ square pan with aluminum foil, grease the inside lightly; set aside. Combine first 3 ingredients in a medium saucepan, then cook over medium-high heat, stirring constantly, until mixture comes to a boil; cook 3 minutes, keep on stirring!  Remove from heat and add the white chocolate morsels, marshmallow cream, 2 cups crushed cookies, and salt.  Stir until everything melts together. Pour fudge into the 9×13″ pan, then sprinkle remaining 1 cup of crushed cookies over the top of the fudge, gently pressing cookies into fudge.  Cover and chill in fridge until firm. Lift fudge in aluminum foil from pan; remove foil and cut fudge into squares. Eat!

These cookies you don’t even really need a recipe for, they are so easy! But really quick to make and festive! Sadie loved helping me sprinkle on the broken candy canes! (and then she stealthily stole the leftover candy canes off the tree and ate them in her closet. I kid you not)

White Chocolate Dipped Peppermint Cookies


Mint Chocolate cookies (aka grasshopper cookies from the Keebler brand)
white chocolate or almond bark
candy canes, crushed

Melt chocolate bark and dip each cookie in, lifting it out with a fork and gently tapping to get rid of the extra chocolate, then slide it off the fork onto wax paper. Sprinkle with crushed candy canes right away! Almond bark sets up fast if you’re using that. Let cool and harden. Done!


  1. Oh my goodness, I need to make some of these cookies (and buy some cute boxes for them to go in!).
    How did you decorate your sugar cookies? They look so professional!

  2. These look amazing! I did my own fair share of baking this past weekend. I love the idea of the treat boxes!

  3. These look beautiful! I’d LOVE to hear your royal icing tips…mine used to turn out great but lately I’m having major problems and can’t figure out why.

  4. oh I love sugar cookie decorating too- it’s one of my favorite Christmas traditions. unfortunately I haven’t made any yet and I’m obviously almost out of time, especially since I’ve still go a pair of pajamas and a teepee to sew before Christmas. but your cookies are so inspiring, maybe I could find the time….

  5. You are a freaking homemaking wizard. No doubt at all.
    If I tried to make your cookies, they would turn out like this:

  6. You ARE a freaking homemaking wizard!!!

  7. ñam ñam!!

  8. Ooh, yummy yummy! I want to try those sugar cookies. =) Well, and all the rest of them.

  9. They look beautiful and very yummy, I think I’ll try out the sugar cookies with my 3 daughters 🙂 Thanks for sharing!

  10. Um, I agree with your friend! You are a freaking homemaking wizard! Own it, girlfriend 🙂

  11. Jessica, You are truly freaking awesome! Those treat boxes are amazing esp. knowing that you have two little girls and a NEWBORN BABY to take care of at the moment. WOW. I’m going to copy this post into my DO NEXT YEAR list. You are always an inspiration to me. Hope you and your family have a beautiful holiday.

  12. These all look amazing. I can not wait to give the sugar cookie recipe a go, it looks pretty easy too. Where did you find your icing recipe?

  13. What kind of coloring did you use for the frosting? I love those colors! So cute!

  14. I am wondering where to get the Christmas tree cookie cutter that you used for the Christmas cookies?

  15. So the sugar cookies don’t need baking powder? Every other recipe I’ve used calls for it.

  16. Would it be possible to use all vanilla extract for the Christmas sugar cookies recipe? Making Halloween shapes for a no nut sports team.


  1. […] my Christmas sugar cookies never looked like this, until I discovered this fabulous recipe on the Craftiness Is Not Optional Blog. Be sure to stop by anytime you need a dose of some sweet […]

  2. […] Christmas Cookie Recipe – Craftiness is Not Optional […]

  3. […] Perfect Sugar Cookies from Craftiness Is Not Optional […]

  4. […] | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | […]

  5. […] Sugar Cookies 2// Red Velvet Fudge 3// Peppermint Mocha Cupcakes 4// Baked Apples 5// Red Velvet Pancakes 6// […]

  6. […] used this sugar cookie recipe and this royal icing […]

  7. […] Craftiness is not Optional: The Perfect Sugar Cookies […]

  8. […] cookie recipe I used came from Here  and the icing is from […]

  9. […] used this sugar cookie recipe and this royal icing recipe. I did have to use a lot more icing than I expected as well as a lot of […]

  10. […] 1. Perfect sugar cookies with royal icing by Craftiness is Not Optional 2. Christmas tree cookies perfect to treat a crowd by Sweetopia 3. Fabulous mini gingerbread house […]

  11. […] Christmas Sugar Cookies are fun treats. […]

  12. […] to the vanilla. I LOVE almond extract and found the flavor it added to these to be irresistible. Get this one here! One thing I found helpful here too is to always keep your dough cold – this will help it cut […]

  13. […] Yogurt in the Instant Pot, Garlic and Herb Pull-Apart Bread, Iced Sugar Cookies, Grinch […]

  14. […] Icing is the key ingredient in the Perfect Sugar Cookies from Craftiness is not Optional. Too pretty to eat? Maybe. But we’ll take our […]

  15. […] // Cheesecake Cookies // Thumbprint Snowman Cookies // Cake Batter Chocolate Chip Cookies // The Perfect Sugar Cookies with Royal Icing // Christmas Swirl Sugar Cookies // Banana Double Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies // Grinch Cookies // […]

Speak Your Mind